Memories of Holdenshire.

As Eronar takes place in the chair, Tinbellow asks him "So, do I shave you bald like your friend over there?", then to answer Chester's query, Tinbellow shrugs "The well is a bit of an oddity, it emits this whistling sound, nobody knows why exactly. It attracts the odd curious, at least those brave, stupid, or desperate enough to come to the Redwall district. Then of course, it's also our local source of water, so you'll have the occasional resident coming there to get a pale full of clean water..."

Tinbellow cuts Eronar's hair, as requested. "That'll be 2 gold pieces. Anyone else in need of anything?"

Quick TL;DR for @ChrSch so they're not stock reading 10 pages of posts to catch up.

The only thing that makes sense right now is if we pretend you were part of the group all along...

You all woke up in a dungeon with no memories, weapons drawn, surrounding a dying female adventurer who seemed happy that you "finally broke free" before she died of her wounds. Further inspection revealed the wounds were inflicted in a fight against a wasp-like entity which seems to have taken over your minds and enrolled you all into a cult, probably against your will. While you remember who you are, you have huge gaps in your memories, especially where how you got here and how you got involved into a cult is concerned.

You then proceeded through a sort of "reverse dungeon" which had already been (mostly) cleared by the dead female adventurer you had identified as Annika Crestveil.

You eventually made your way out of the complex where you met a halfling named Belton Freedew who informed you that you were in the Redwall district of Northminster, that you were indeed part of a cult and wanted criminals, knew about someone who could help you with your memories, and that he was willing to smuggle you out of town if you were willing to help him with some errands.

Where the party is at right now, you had just taken care of getting the dried yewclaw bark from Tinbellows and were asking the doctor about the two goblins Muggs and Runns... with a few party member getting a haircut hoping it would alter their appearance enough to not get caught...

So, that should be you all caught up.

As Zaiachi waits outside, he catches a fragment of conversation from two passerbys.

"...yeah, found him in that alley over there, wasn't much left o' him..."

"Waddya mean?'

"Just bones and torn clothes really, like something ate his flesh and left the rest behind...

So, you're done getting your head shaved, Zaiashi who has always been with you (wink, wink, nudge, nudge) enters and informs you of a rumor he just heard concerning a dead body.

What do you do?

"That would be The Thrifty Griffon." Tinbellows answers.

From Tinbellow's and Belton's directions, as well as what you've walked so far, you can estimate roughly the following map...

With A being where you exited the complex, B being the Thrifty Griffin, C being the Whistling Well (where you should in theory find Runns and Muggs), and D being Tinbellow's Medical Practice, where you currently are all located.

You make your way north of Tinbellow's practice towards the Whistling Well. Eventually, just following the low whistling sound is enough to guide you. Near an old worn well, you spot two goblins. The larger one wears a large sweater and a bowler hat and is currently smoking a cigar. The smaller of the pair is wearing a long trench coat. The area around the well seems large enough to be used as a meeting place if need be, but right now, there is nobody here except you and the two goblins.