You're part of the fourth generation of superheroes; the Golden Age heroes from the 30's are long gone, the Silver Age cosmic powers are mostly gone (or fighting galaxy scale events you couldn't even begin to understand), and the current era of Bronze Age grittier heroes are standing sentinel over Halcyon and similar cities around the world. The eyes of the world are on you, ready to label you one way or another while you try to carve out your identity.
You've all chosen to be on a team with each other; for whatever reason you've chosen to stick together as a team. None of you are killers, none of you are openly being hunted by the authorities or loved by the populace at large.
So what does everyone feel like playing?