optimumsquare says:
how is this a civilian vessel and not a criminal vessel. I'm still confused on this point. If this is a civilian vessel, why are we approaching it this way? why did we not just hail them and tell them to heave to and submit to a search? It sounds like there is a lot of concern over people who have stolen war supplies, war supplies that could keep clones alive.
These are very good and valid points and we will assume that the questions were raised and answered in the mission briefing:
- The Republic Army and Navy actually don't have the authority to conduct policing activities on private citizens. As the freighter is under a Republic registered trading company the Army would have no cause nor authority to search the vessel.
- The Jedi, however do have the authority to search (with cause and warrant), though with the Republic 'Judicials' not the military. As was stated, the supplies are needed for the war effort thus can not afford to be tied up in a criminal investigation and prosecution (the supplies would be held in evidence). So essentially the covert nature of the mission is to basically steal the supplies back. OR ...
And I'm only loosely going to explain the following, any further detail being IC via conversation with Edite and what she chooses to reveal:
- Being a civilian company with no overt or confirmed Separatists sympathies it would be a PR nightmare to go in guns blazing and treating the entire crew as enemy combatants and there wasn't time to conduct a proper investigation and still secure the stolen supplies ... it also wouldn't do to making a very public 'stop and search' as the Republic relies on private companies to move their supplies as well and companies would be reluctant to work with the Republic if they knew the were using the military to search and seize ships.
- There have been rumors of the Separatists Navy harrowing the shipping lanes and dedicating military resources to protecting shipping is costly and takes away military assests from the front lines. Smugglers caught smuggling stolen Republic supplies however ... can avoid jail time for agreeing to smuggle supplies for the Republic.
- It is also in the troopers experience that when Republic Intelligence is involved that there are other motives in play that the troopers aren't made privy to.