Star Trek Adventure

Does anyone here place Star Trek Adventure? Is anyone interested?

I'd be interested, I've dabbled with the system a little bit.

Hmm.. thoughts to get beamed up.

What’s StarTrek Adventure? I mean I get the StarTrek part but it’s such a broad spectrum of time and such.

Star Trek Adventures is a Star Trek ttrpg ruleset by Modiphius. Link to more information. I have not played it yet.

Someone tried to start a game last year, but we didn't get past chargen for a number of reasons. The Modiphius rules system looks interesting.

Still a valid question to ask about which era as that system explicitly supports both TOS and TNG era Trek

I was in two games that did not get off the ground

Star Trek sits in a weird space (no pun intended) for an RPG. On the one hand, it's a very precise and technical setting that would lend itself to a more 'crunchy' system like the old FASA ST RPG game but it also plays fast and loose with action and plot and lend itself to something more casual and 'rule of cool' like the Mophidius' STAdventures rules. Players expecting one type of game are often disappointed when it turns out to be the other and with a mix of players Star Trek games often flounder.
The Mophidius' 2d20 rules for Star Trek Adventures covers a much more narritively driven game and is much less rules-driven than previous Star Trek RPG iterations. It's fun in a much more casual sense but does lend itself to a lot of plot stretching actions by players being possible. The one aspect I really liked out of the STA rules was the inclusion of the ship as a passive character in the story, something I think was missing from a lot of games with a ship/base as a focal point.

I'd be interested in joining a game. I have some experience with Modiphius' 2d20 system (the Dune 2d20 system) and have read parts of the STA rulebook, but never played it.

I don't think a very crunchy system makes much sense for Star Trek. It's not a setting about strategic fights and firmly established rules of technology and weapons. It's just about stories and themes and I feel like a light system is more suited for that focus, personally.
But it's an interesting discussion, witchdoctor!

Honestly, I think the level of crunch might be dependent on the era. TOS would definitely benefit from a more narritive and less crunchy system (due to the high weirdness factor if nothing else) whereas DS9 might be better suited to a more well defined and stricter set of rules given the difference in overall themes of the two shows. DS9 has a more grounded and consequential feel than TOS and that may be why I feel that way.
Trek games can be about big stories or small, grand adventures and personal development but it's definitely different things to different players and their preferences. Personally, I tend more towards the more 'grounded' feel of crunchy systems and the stories they generate. The last time I ran a Trek campaign it was in the vein of Starfleet Battles Prime Teams than the standard fare. I used Chaosium's base RPG system adapted to Trek to run it and it fared pretty well but I think that was because the players were all in the same page as far as game expectations.

I'm sure discussions about this can be had. I tend more towards lighter systems and I feel like a light system would also work far better for DS9 than a heavier one. Even the more militaristic episodes aren't really about the fighting, except as a theme

Is this an interest check thread or a system discussion thread?

Good point, thank you. That discussion is probably more suited to the Discord or a separate thread. Let's get back on topic.

Crunchy or Light systems are both valid points to start just about any game and neither has an inherent benefit over the other. As you tend towards lighter systems, I suppose I tend more towards crunchier ones and that's okay. As long as the gm and the players all gave fun with their selection, it's all good! The 2d20 Star Trek Adventures system should work pretty well for whatever the OP intends.

I was more interested in what the setting would be. Was StarTrek ever crunchy? I didn't watch a lot of DS9 but seemed that in every other series the big problem was always solved in the last 5 minutes by someone reversing the polarity on something. =)

Back on topic then. Are we looking for players and/or a GM?

and is there a story or would you be building it?

I am interested in the idea.