"Perhaps you can tell us, Mr. Madison, when was the last time Memphis left on such a trip, prior to this current disappearance? Might you know where he traveled to?"
"No, nothing that sticks out in my memory. His last trip was a tour of western Europe for his stage show. England, France, Germany, Spain, and Portugal I believe. He was gone for several months."
"Well, if we are to look over the home and investigate, it seems this to be a place you know much better than any of us. Is there anything we should be aware of? Nothing particularly or abnormally dangerous or curious to your eye, is there?"
"Oh, no, sir, I wouldn't work in a place that was dangerous. Memphis is a great magician, sir, it's all smoke and mirrors. Nothing dangerous about him or his tricks. Besides the unfortunate deaths there has been nothing dangerous about the house at all."
"Right, ok," Yuna leans forward, a glean in her eye, "So, Mr. Madison. What you've told us is two men were killed there, you watch the home, take care of it, there's nothing out of the ordinary and nothing dangerous otherwise. In a sense, you have told us absolutely nothing that Mr. Pickering couldn't have told us. So why did he bring you in here? Why talk to us at all?"
Charles brings the cup of coffee, which had been offered at reception, up to his lips; the perfect way to hide the smile breaking across his face.
The reporter had a keen mind, and a cutting way with words. Charles often fancied himself in such a way, but he couldn’t quite get a handle on his verbosity.
Mr. Madison runs a hand through his hair. "Well, I suppose, because I found the bodies and Mr. Pickering didn't. Also there were three men killed, not two. But besides the police who arrived and took the bodies away, I'm the only one who knows the...circumstances of their demise."
Yuna's eyes narrow, a thin smile hitting her lips. "Right, three. How clumsy of me. Now - that's an interesting point. I had assumed they shot each other, but that's also rather clumsy on my part. I'm guessing from your hesitation these circumstances were not so clear-cut, hmm?"
Mr. Gardener bobs his head in a nod. "Right you are, ma'am. A lot of assumptions. If the men had just shot each other I wouldn't be here. And I wouldn't have nightmares about it. Or pieces of it rather. It was a bit much to take in all at once. I just remember a lot of blood, bulging eyes, blood-soaked shirts. They had all stabbed, cut, and hanged each other. But what I dream about is the hand. One severed hand with its fingers still twitching. In my dreams sometimes it beckons to me, other times it wags its finger in disappointment like my ma used to do when I was a child. The rest is hazy. Maybe I don't want to remember it. I'm sure the police have all the gory details that are too much for my stomach."
A look of horror on his face, Barrington shudders at Mr Gardener's gruesome description of the death scene. Collecting himself, he swallows and then asks:
"Do I understand right, Mr Gardener, that three people had stabbed, cut, and hanged each other? Or was that just the fate of two of them, and something else - I assume similarly awful - happened to a third? Or is the third person you refer to the twitching-fingered severed hand?"
"A follow up to that - do you surmise that all three people were burglars? If that is what you assume for two of them, then what of the third?"
"And finally - why didn't you tell us that a third person was involved from the beginning?"
"Yes, all three were killed. They were all brothers. I didn't mention it because it didn't occur to me that you would jump to the conclusion it was just two. The brothers were well known in this city so I also assumed you might have known. I do, however, think there was a fourth. The police think otherwise. How could three brothers turn on each other and all die of their wounds leaving no survivor? It baffles the mind. But I am not a detective, just a simple groundskeeper, so what do I know about the minds of burglars and apparent killers?"
"A groundskeeper may be needed on the question of a fourth. Perhaps, if you were to imagine yourself as a criminal man, you might tell us where such a trio, if indeed it was three, might enter the property.
A hedge that allows access to the grounds, but is hidden to the eye? A gate, unknown to most, left unlocked for ease of passage after hours?
It’s there we may find a four-set of prints entering the property, and a single set returning.
If indeed there was a fourth. Besides that, it sounds like it may be necessary to engage with the police on the grisly details!"
Mr. Gardener clears his throat. "I'm sorry if there was a misunderstanding. The police concluded there were only three. No evidence whatsoever of four. That was just my speculation as to how all three--brothers no less--have killed each other with no survivors. The thieves broke into Memphis' prop room on the first floor, smashing through the window and crawling through. I would assume they knew no one was home and probably wouldn't be for days if not longer and were not too subtle about their burglary attempt. But you are correct the police know more about the investigation than I."
"Ah, well… perhaps the fourth brother will remain in our dramatic retellings of this story at dinners with our associates!" he says, giving a brief laugh to signal the book being closed on the issue.
"I suspect our keen eyed reporter here will have a contact at the police department. Would that be right, Ms. Yuna?"
"I do," Yuna says with a nod, "and it appears we've exhausted the limits of your assistance for the time being. Mr. Gardener, thank you for your time. I could have follow-up questions, if you'll remain in town. Will you continue to be staying at Memphis's home, or...?"
"Oh, I don't live on the premises. I have my own place with my wife. I'll leave you my address. I hope I have been of some help to solve this mystery. Mr. Memphis doesn't deserve to have his reputation tarnished by this horrible event."
Mr. Pickering opens the door and thanks the caretaker for his time. After shutting the door he turns to all of you. The lawyer fishes a key from his pocket and hands it to the young reporter. "A key to the Memphis house. Please treat the house with respect during your inquiries. In addition, I will offer a $100 reward for solving this mystery. The police officer in charge of the investigation was Inspector Edwards if you want to find more about the official case. Good luck."