I forgot to reply to this...
Cep100 says:
I suppose, I always just thought that the color pattern seemed really ethnocentric, is all. Red in China, for example, is a color associated with joy and celebration, something you wear to a wedding, because red is the color of blood and it's associated with life. But Taoism, as a belief purports that if you try to say one aspect of life is good or evil that you are missing the point and are further from the Tao. Basically that saying any color of a crystal has any reflection of ethics or morals is adhering to an extreme. Like I could get behind it if red was the color of high emotions but not, specifically, evil and selfishness.
I think you've already put way more thought into Lighsaber colour than George Lucas ever did.
His rule was "all good guy sabers are blue, all bad guy sabers are red", without any in-universe reason for that.
We only ever got green because ILM couldn't make blue look good against a blue sky background in that fight over the Sarlacc. And that of course opened the floodgates for all sorts of colours in comics and games and whatnot.
Quote:
The main reason it applies to Ian is that, if this were D&D, he'd be Chaotic Neutral because he swings wildly from pulling mean pranks (which are bad) to deeply caring about the feelings of others (good) back to intentionally causing trouble (bad) because he feels lonely and wants attention (neutral) all the way to never truly getting angry at his friends because whatever's happening in the moment is just a moment (good). And if his lightsaber starts changing between colors as fast as his moods I will be sort of annoyed.
Well, according to current canon, a crystal attunes to your personality, not your current mood, and it doesn't change again once it's attuned even if your personality changes or if the crystal gets a new owner.
Quote:
And whether or not Palpatine was a 'good' Sith he was the only one who seemed really happy with his place in life and for some reason that jovial love of evil was more intimidating than anger or anything else. I know a lot of people liked Kreia, for example, and she was an interesting concept but EVERY time she opened her mouth I was thinking 'christ, grandma's telling her stories from the Great Depression again . . . Yes, the fools on the Jedi high council never watered down their juice and that's why they all had to die . . .'
Yeah, I love how he just glorifies in his villainy. Iain McDiarmid is a treasure who frequently seemed to be in an entirely different film than his po-faced opponents.