IC Story Thread: Ch.1,Ad.1 - A Sensitive Matter

load previous
Jan 22, 2024 10:01 pm
"Perhaps it will be best to act on the new moon... the night will be darker, and the skies themselves will shield us from prying eyes..."

He looks at his companions, "I think the next new moon is..."
OOC:
rolling Nature to see how precise an idea Cirion has of the phases of the moon
... But he realizes his recollections are vague. "I am not sure, actually..."
Last edited January 22, 2024 10:07 pm

Rolls

Nature - (1d20+1)

(7) + 1 = 8

Jan 22, 2024 10:32 pm
OOC:
The actual date is not important. I was just telling you that, yes, he can relay your message.

Is there any other prep you guys want to do? As mentioned the Rangers would take checks to find, but they would have other information too.

Or do we still want to do it at all?

Not sure if ppl are just busy kicking off the New Year?

Or if there's hesitancy, or disinterest in this?

But seems like momentum is dragging right now.
Jan 23, 2024 2:15 am
OOC:
My hesitancy comes from not being sure if this is a sidetrack from the main adventure/scenario. If it will even provide anything of help to us in the main adventure/scenario. Also, we have very little information on what to expect on the other side of the river, so no idea if we are capable of surviving.

I am happy to go if the everyone else in the group is in favour. For the reasons given above I do not have strong desire to go, but would go out of curiousity if everyone was in favour of it.
Jan 23, 2024 7:24 am
Éothain frowns. "Talking to the sergeant was helpful, in that I do not think the risk is worth the information we might find. Who are we to go where the Gondorian patrol fears to tread? I am sorry that I may have wasted everyone's time. I suggest we wait until Lady Blackridge's agents return."
Jan 23, 2024 3:56 pm
OOC:
Yea, I mean it's definitely a side quest.

But it would, at the least, provide information that your characters don't necessarily know in character, but that as players ooc you probably know at least in part (depending on how big of a Tolkien nerd you are).

And when you're venturing into ruins, there's always the chance that there "may" be other things found that you didn't know about going into into it too... :)

Basically, for stuff like this, where there may be interest outside of but within the scope of the main quest (or with character background/story stuff), as DM I see it as my job to put story where the interest is.

I'm going to try to make sure it's not a waste of time for us. I'm going to try to make it interesting. I'm going to try to make it challenging (but I'm not going to try to kill you with it).

And also I'm going to try to make sure it doesn't take TOO much IRL time.

Basically - we're not ever EVER going to be just floating in the wind here, doing stuff without reason and risking death for nothing, when I'm DMing. I'm always always going to try to be creating a cohesive and purposeful and mindful and hopefully fun and interesting experience for us as a group.

But if there is more interest in the main quest right now, we can remain focused on that, and always circle back around to this if we want to later.
Jan 23, 2024 10:08 pm
OOC:
I'm good either way. I'm invested in the main quest and curious about Osgiliath but ok with skipping it to stay on the main story. It seems like Drakis and rpgventurer prefer to skip the side quest. Fine by me.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on DMing, emsquared. You are doing a great job.

Any hesitancy/ lack of posting from my side is only due to RL family/work balance intruding on my gamersplane time occasionally creating the dilemma of post or sleep. So nothing to do with game engagement.
Jan 23, 2024 10:28 pm
Stefron says:
OOC:
I'm good either way. I'm invested in the main quest and curious about Osgiliath but ok with skipping it to stay on the main story. It seems like Drakis and rpgventurer prefer to skip the side quest. Fine by me.
OOC:
Ok, and given that Dr_B was also "either way", maybe we just pursue the main storyline for now, and again, we could still circle back to this later.

I'll start a new thread and put together an opening post for the next adventure!

Thanks all.
Jan 24, 2024 4:05 pm
OOC:
Sounds good to me.

Also, I echo @Stefron comments about your DMing. Enjoying the adventure, and the opportunity to "live" in Tolkein's world a little bit. Likewise my hesitancy is down to RL, and also not being sure about the scenario. Your summary helped get it clear in my head.

Thread locked