Chapter 2: Fell Tunnels

Is Hrafe making an opportunity attack? If so none occurred. If someone makes a disengage check and fails, it means they don't move after all. If he had moved without a disengage check, then you could have attacked.

Alll good, we are all learning. You haven't done much with disengaging other than the boss of chapter 1 getting away

I could have sworn when I read that post the first time it just said Edgar's turn. That's why I was asking if I should go on not in the 1-on-1 thread. Sorry for the confusion.

Lot's going on with flexible attacks, so I hope this flows easily since I don't know AC exactly.

Action: Flexible Ranged vs. HO2
-- If it misses, it'll trigger Carve an Opening, and Comeback Strike. Deals 2 miss damage, Crit Range is 18+ now, and another attack at -2.
-- If it hits somehow, it'll trigger Carve an Opening and deal 2d10+3 damage.

When/if Comeback Strike is triggered, it rolled a 12:
-- If it misses with a 12, that's it, deal 2 more miss damage and turn over.
-- If it hits with a 12, it'll trigger, Deadly Assault, and I'll reroll any 1s and 2s on the damage.

Either way, the damage on a hit will be 2d10+3, so I'll just roll that, and then reroll any 1s and 2s just in case and there aren't any 1s or 2s so Deadly Assault does nothing.

I see carve an opening only works with melee attacks. Is there a rule I am unaware of or w conversation we had where that works with ranged attacks against enemies you are engaged with?

I think I'm too far away to attack the elf, right?

Makasi is too far from the elf to move and attack, but I you want to dedicate your entire turn to moving then you can engage either elf, but you won't be able to attack that same turn.
As a side note, these elves appear to be high elves. Edgar knows what that means mechanically.

Did Edgar want to make just a basic attack or use an at-will power? The attack missed, but Edgar could have used one instead of just a basic attack. Not required though. Keep in mind E1 is not staggered, and Edgar did not have momentum.

Also, did you engage with only E1, or did you move to AM16, which would have you engaged with both elves?

Will move to AM16. Just used a basic attack as without Momentum or the need use Evasive Strike none really seem to apply.

Move to AL8-ish, action: ranged flexible attack vs E2, using Power Attack (+1d4 damage), triggers Precision Attack (+3) damage