Ch. 1 - The Keep on the Borderlands
Be sure to read and follow the guidelines for our forums.
Regarding Phantasmal Force: I'll say you can change the form of the illusion, but the gnolls will get a new saving throw each time.
Rolls
Morgan: short bow attack, damage - (1d20+1, 1d6)
1d20+1 : (6) + 1 = 7
1d6 : (3) = 3
Rolls
Shortbow shot, damage - (1d20, 1d6)
1d20 : (18) = 18
1d6 : (3) = 3
Edit: Oh, might as well make my attack for round 2 as well...
Rolls
Sling attack. - (1d20-2, 1d4)
1d20-2 : (9) - 2 = 7
1d4 : (4) = 4
Sling attack (round 2) - (1d20-1, 1d4)
1d20-1 : (1) - 1 = 0
1d4 : (2) = 2
Rolls
Shortbow - (1d20, 1d6)
1d20 : (10) = 10
1d6 : (6) = 6
Rolls
Secret Roll
Farem lines up a shot and fires at one of the gnolls, wounding it. Father Petronius slings a stone but misses. Kraagor continues to charge ahead, moving another 30 yards; he is now just 100 yards away from them!
Rolls
Secret Roll
Rolls
Sling attack (round 3) - (1d20, 1d4)
1d20 : (5) = 5
1d4 : (3) = 3
Rolls
Darlene vs. gnolls - (1d20, 1d6)
1d20 : (13) = 13
1d6 : (4) = 4
Rolls
Shortbow shot, damage - (1d20, 1d6)
1d20 : (1) = 1
1d6 : (4) = 4
@ChrSch, @AbbyssalChimera are the last to go this round.
Rolls
Morgan: short bow attack, damage - (1d20+1, 1d6)
1d20+1 : (15) + 1 = 16
1d6 : (1) = 1
Secret Roll
Rolls
Sling attack (round 4) - (1d20, 1d4)
1d20 : (20) = 20
1d4 : (1) = 1
Rolls
Attack and damage - (1d20, 1d6)
1d20 : (10) = 10
1d6 : (6) = 6
Rolls
Attack - (1d20)
(9) = 9
Damage (just in case) - (1d6)
(2) = 2
Rolls
Shortbow - (1d20, 1d6)
1d20 : (10) = 10
1d6 : (5) = 5