Part 1: Goblin Arrows

Actually, before you finalize this, please give me a moment to post Round 2. I messed up in Round 1, and as a result Mathias should have taken no damage. I'll explain this mistake in more detail in today's post, which should be uploaded in the next 60 minutes or so. After you've read today's post feel free to reconsider your choice for Mathias's turn.

First and foremost, I need to apologise. In Round 1, I had made an error regarding missile weapon ranges and coinciding attack rolls. Ranged weapons in 5e have 2 numbers, separated by a "/". The first number is normal range, and the second number is long range. I operated under the misunderstanding that firing at a distance under normal range gives the attacker Advantage, and firing at a distance between normal and long was a regular To Hit roll. This is incorrect. Firing at a distance up to the normal range is a normal roll, and firing at a distance between the normal and long range limit is at Disadvantage. Because of that, Goblin 1’s attack on Mathias should not have been at Advantage simply for being within the normal range limits. I should only have made 1 To Hit roll, which would have been the first roll. As this roll was a "1", the result should have been automatic failure. For this reason, the damage done to Mathias will be retconned and he remains currently at full health.

Alstaer has the next turn in Initiative order, followed by the goblins, then Quinny’s post will be recognised. I will give @AOC1996 the opportunity to revise their post, due to my mistake in Round 1, though if you still wish for Mathias to use his battleaxe attack on Goblin 2 (R8) and want to keep the "17" To Hit roll, I will allow it.

I'll keep my actions, minus the use of Second Wind! Thank you!

It is Severus’s turn to finish up this round, and then we’ll start the next one.

In 5e, Initiative rolls are made at the beginning of the encounter, and turn order remains the same every round of the encounter.
You do not re-roll Initiative every turn.

That being said, I cannot emphasize enough how important it is that you don't post your PCs action until your turn is up. This is especially true if your PCs turn comes after the enemy's turn. If you post that your character is moving to a specific space and attacking a specific target, and the enemy's turn comes before yours and they move to a different space on the battlemap, you've basically moved your token to an empty space and forfeited your action for the round. If you post out of turn, and your posting becomes obsolete by the time your PC's turn comes up in the round, you forfeit your turn. As the DM, there's is no guarantee I'm going to leave a monster standing in a specific place simply because someone declared out of turn that they were going to attack that monster when their PC's turn eventually comes up later in Initiative order.

At this point we're still resolving Severus's actions for Round 2. I'm going to assume that this is going to be Quinny's Action when her turn comes up in Round 3. I appreciate the enthusiasm and I'm going to allow it this time, but from here on out I'm going to insist that players don't post their PC's actions until I declare a new round has begun, and I strongly recommend you wait until your PC's turn is actually up or risk your post turning obsolete as circumstances change.

Round 2 ends! Round 3 begins!
Turn order is as follows:
-->1. Osvaldo
2. Alstaer
3. Goblins
4. Quinny
5. Mathias
6. Severus

Mathias and Severus have Goblin 2 flanked, and any melee attacks by Mathias and Severus are at Advantage against Goblin 2 only assuming the Goblin is still alive and flanked on their turn.

Oh, I'm confused. This is Quinny's move for round 2. The one where she move to J10 was on Round 1. [ Link to Post ]

NOW Round 3 begins!

While the goblin isn’t hidden (he failed to roll higher than anyone’s Passive Perception on his "Hide" Bonus Action, he does benefit from ¾ cover, meaning his armor class is at +5 while in the trees.

Turn order is as follows:
1. Osvaldo
2. Alstaer
3. Goblins
-->4. Quinny
5. Mathias
6. Severus

Quinny has resistance to piercing damage when in rage. Is the 5 the full damage or should I halve it to 3? Quinny's down to 10 HP.

Mathias seems to have left the game btw. Just in case DM didn't notice or was told

Ah yes, thank you for the catch! You are correct. With Quinny's Rage, she only takes 2HP of Damage and should be at 13 now.

Hmm, I didn't catch that... Alright, we'll sort it out later.

For the moment, it appears that the encounter is over with three dead goblins and one currently captive. Mathias, Osvaldo, and Quinny have been wounded by arrow attacks; some in worse shape than others.

Feel free to ignore Initiative turn orders, as we go bock to roleplaying in character again.