It's not too hard to find Bertrum a healer who can actually help him when you know what's going on, the healer is confused muttering something about this being the third case of whatever this is and he'll have to look into it more later but won't say any more than that.
John doesn't return, and it doesn't take Seline long to find, but weather Gworgi followed him and ate him, or he sailed off is uncertain. Sometimes it's best to not ask too many questions.
The third Criminal, having not spoken is turned in to the Neverwinter Citizen Milita Department (N.C.M.D.) as a way to explain why Pyle disappeared midday, and what you were doing there in a believable way.
OOC:
Welcome to Level 4!
Before I Get questions about Feats, Yes they are allowed
Part 2 will be up soon.